Members only?
Unpacking Spiritual Gifts – 4
1 Cor 12:12-27

I love words. I love the way you can tell stories and paint pictures with them. I love the way that you can play with the sounds. I love the way that just the right word can perfectly capture an idea.

The problem is, of course, that words change.

400 years ago, if you said someone was “nice” it wasn’t a compliment. It meant you thought they were “silly” or “ignorant.” 

150 years ago when you said somebody was a “gentleman” you weren’t making a comment about their manners, simply saying they who owned property and didn’t work at a trade.  

30 years ago “gay” meant happy. When I was in primary school in Scotland I learned a Scottish country dance called “The Gay Gordons.” We used to dance it to a song called “Marie’s Wedding.” Its first line was, “Step we gaily on we go, heel for heel and toe for toe.” I’m not sure what they do with that dance in Scotland these days.

We’re in the middle of a series on Spiritual Gifts, but we can’t talk about spiritual gifts without talking about something else that always comes up in the same context when Paul talks about gifts. Whether it’s Romans 12, 1 Corinthians 12 or Ephesians 4, whenever Paul talks about spiritual gifts, he talks about membership.

What does “membership” mean? Well, if you go to the source of all knowledge in our society (otherwise known as Google) for a definition you get, “the body of members of an organization or group; the state of being a member.” That’s a lot of help! What’s more enlightening is that when I Googled the phrase, “Membership has its privileges!” I got over 121,000 hits!

After I had knee surgery earlier this year I went through a course of physiotherapy. That’s done now, but I still have to work on getting the muscles around my knee back up to strength. I’ve thought of using the gym at the downtown Y so I can keep my knee growing stronger. But, of course, if I want to do that I have to become a member, because the facilities are for the use of members only.

It’s not too hard to become a member of the Y. You just have to live in the Hamilton area and pay the fee. But just down the street is the Hamilton Club. I didn’t even know there was a Hamilton Club until I was working on this sermon. It’s not surprising. The Hamilton Club has less than 350 members. It costs $1500 to join. The annual fees are $2500 (plus GST). And it’s not just the money, if you want to join; you have to be sponsored by 5 people who are already members.

This is what being a “member” means today. It means that you’re on the inside and you have access to privileges that others don’t have. That may mean something as simple as being able to rent a video from a video store, or it may mean having access to an exclusive club. Either way, membership today is about privilege and access to services.

But the meaning has changed. The meaning has changed so much that most of the modern translations of the Bible no longer use the word “member” to translate passages like 1 Cor 12. The NIV uses “part.” 12 The body is a unit, though it is made up of many parts; and though all its parts are many, they form one body. So it is with Christ.

I don’t know about you, but for me “part” just doesn’t cut it. When I think of “body parts” I think of CSI; you know, body parts without the body? But members are more than parts; they are parts that belong together. In fact when they talk in the news about finding a body with parts missing they call it a “dismembered” body.

And anyway, we don’t talk about church “part-ship.” We talk about church “membership.” That’s why this morning I chose a translation that uses the word “member,” so it’s easier to keep in focus what it is we’re talking about.

Unity with Christ means community with Christians

It’s time for another definition. The Oxford English Dictionary defines a “member” as “a part or organ of the body.” That’s the primary meaning Paul has in mind as he writes to the church in Corinth about how they should relate to one another. He says it at the beginning of this passage and again at the end, like bookends.

12 For just as the body is one and yet has many members, and all the members of the body – though many – are one body, so too is Christ... 27 Now you are Christ’s body, and each of you is a member of it.

He says “you (plural; that means all of you together) are Christ’s body.” He doesn’t say you are part of Christ’s body, or related to Christ’s body. No, the believers in Corinth together are Christ’s body. Just like my arms and my legs and my head and my nose and my ears and my belly button, and everything else, together, are my body, so all the believers together in Corinth are the body of Christ.

Being a member the body of Christ isn’t an optional extra. You can’t choose to follow Jesus and then later decide whether or not you want to be a member of his body any more than you have random arms and legs lying around that decide one day that they want to be part of a body. Unity with Christ means community with Christians. Being united with Christ, being “in Christ” as Paul puts it, isn’t some kind of mystical union that you can have by yourself. It is, by definition, being part of the visible body of Christ. If you want a private religious experience, then the church is the wrong place to come. You can be a Buddhist by yourself, but you can’t be a Christian by yourself.

Because we were all baptized into the one body

Because, (v13) “in one Spirit we were all baptized into one body. Whether Jews or Greeks or slaves or free, we were all made to drink of the one Spirit. 14 For in fact the body is not a single member, but many.”

Baptism doesn’t make you a member of the body of Christ, that’s the work of the Holy Spirit. But baptism is our visible act of testimony to what God has done and is doing in our lives through the Holy Spirit. It doesn’t matter where you came from, or what your background is; Jew or Greek, slave or free, upper-class middle-class working-class or poor. It doesn’t matter if you’re a doctor or you didn’t finish high school, if you’re geeky or cool, if you’re young or old. None of that matters because “in one Spirit we were all baptized into one body.” And that body is the body of Christ, the church.

Two attitudes to avoid

But people are still different. Even if we get over our different backgrounds, we are all differently gifted, and that’s how it should be. We’re not all trying to conform to some kind of cookie-cutter pattern of what the perfect Christian looks like. Even so, there are a couple of common responses that Paul warns us to avoid.

“I don’t belong”

The first response is, “I don’t belong here.”

In April 1995 I was in Delhi, India as part of a gathering of leaders in Youth With A Mission. I was there because Marilyn and I were the senior YWAMers in Pakistan (which is pretty easy when you’re the only ones) and the meetings were about restructuring YWAM in South and Central Asia. On the first morning of the meetings we opened with some worship then went to prayer. I can remember thinking to myself, “I don’t belong here.” There was Steve Cochrane; he had pioneered the Muslim work in India and had been on the field for 15 years. His wife Elizabeth had been in jail in Nepal for preaching the gospel there. Georgina Bennett had planted churches and established YWAM bases in North East India and then gone on to do the same thing all over again in Kazakhstan. And the list went on. There were about 20 people in the room and as I sat there and tried to pray all I could think of was. “What am I doing here? I don’t belong here. I’m not even in the same class as these folks.” And God spoke very clearly into my mind, gave me a picture of one of those little plastic wedges that you put under a door and said, “I just want you to be a doorstop. Hold the door open in Pakistan.”

Paul says, 15 If the foot says, “Since I am not a hand, I am not part of the body,” it does not lose its membership in the body because of that. 16 And if the ear says, “Since I am not an eye, I am not part of the body,” it does not lose its membership in the body because of that. 17 If the whole body were an eye, what part would do the hearing? If the whole were an ear, what part would exercise the sense of smell?

It’s really easy to look at other people and say, “I don’t have the experiences and abilities that those guys over there have, so I can’t really be a member of the Body of Christ. I don’t belong.” Well, my feet might not be as elegant or as flexible as my hands, but my body wouldn’t get very far without them. Every part of the body is important and we have no right to decide that we are somehow less useful than someone else. So, for six years in Pakistan I was called to be a foot, stuck in the door to hold it open for others. I would have preferred to be a hand, serving people, or a mouth, proclaiming the gospel, but I was a foot, holding the door open for others who came into the country to do those things.

I couldn’t say, “Because I am not Arley (whose Persian is phenomenal), or Len (whose understanding of Pushtun culture is so profound), or Joey (who could start programmes out of thin air), I don’t belong in the body.” Each one of us, each one of you, is gifted in a unique way that is essential to the body of Christ, because, “God has placed each of the members in the body just as he decided.”

“They don’t belong”

Folks with a low estimate of their own importance tend to look at others and say, since “I’m not as good at whatever as he is, I obviously don’t belong here.” Folks with a high estimate of their importance are more likely to look at people and say, “Well, they’re not like me, obviously they don’t belong here.” But, just as we can’t exclude ourselves, so we also can’t exclude others. 21 The eye cannot say to the hand, “I do not need you,” nor in turn can the head say to the foot, “I do not need you.”

If we don’t take this warning seriously our churches can become clubs for spiritual elitists; or for that matter, spiritual couch potatoes. The church of the spiritual superstars would make sure that only people who were spiritual like them could be part of the church. The church of the couch potatoes would make sure that anybody who sought to go further and deeper with God was made to feel like they were fanatics. Either way, they would make sure that everybody was just like them.

But Paul makes it clear that, “those members that seem to be weaker are essential” (v22). If we have no room for members who seem weaker, then we’re missing the mark of what the body of Christ is supposed to be. What makes a person a member of the body of Christ is the work of the Spirit in their lives, not some standard of spiritual performance.

 23 and those members we consider less honorable we clothe with greater honor, and our unpresentable members are clothed with dignity, 24 but our presentable members do not need this. Instead, God has blended together the body, giving greater honor to the lesser member, 25 so that there may be no division in the body,

When I was in Pakistan I would never go out of the house wearing shorts and a tee-shirt even though the temperature went up to 50C. It would have been like going out in my underwear. People would have said I was “luch”, “naked,” because you don’t show your arms and legs in public. You honour them by covering them up. In the same way, Paul is saying that just because some body parts aren’t normally on display it doesn’t mean that we cut them off. On the contrary, it means that we take extra care of them by covering them with clothing, we clothe them with honour.

So what does this have to do with people in the church using their gifts? What it does is turn everything on its head. Our natural tendency is to honour those who have the most public ministry. That’s the way the world works. When I was at the Hamilton Roundtable for Poverty Reduction the mayor was there, as were a bunch of provincial politicians. All of them were greeted by name from the platform and thanked for coming, and honoured. Everybody else, including the folks who work with street youth and food banks and stuff like that, was greeted in a kind of blanket, “we’re glad you’re all here” way. Because that’s what you do, right?

Not in the church. Paul’s point is that those who have public gifts, or more spectacular gifts, don’t need to be honoured. Their gift brings them enough honour just in what they do. He says, “our presentable members (those who are highly visible) do not need this” extra honour. Just as the bits of our bodies that are acceptable in public don’t need the extra honour of being clothed, so those who are in higher profile public ministry don’t need any extra honour. It’s the people whose gifts lead them to minister in quiet, unassuming ways that we should be honouring. People like: Jeannette, who types up the bulletin every week and answers the phone; Georgie, who keeps the drop-in running; Helen and Sheila and their team of  people who cook the meals for the drop in; Butch, who’s working hard to see that we have a library; the folks who setup communion every month, or count the offering every week. These are the ones that need to be recognised and encouraged.

One attitude to adopt

Caring for one another

That only happens when “the members… have mutual concern for one another.” (v25) If there are two attitudes to avoid, there is one to adopt; caring for one another. For the first couple of months after my surgery I walked with a limp, because my left leg was compensating for my right. I didn’t have to tell it to do that. It did it because it was part of my body and “If one member suffers, everyone suffers with it.” (v26) My left leg was caring for my right, making sure it didn’t take any more weight than it had to until it was strong enough. It didn’t tell my right leg that it had to be amputated and wait until it was strong again before it could rejoin my body. Amputated legs don’t get stronger, they die. The same happens to amputated Christians, who are either cut off from the body, or cut themselves off from the body.

But, if the members suffer together, they also rejoice together. If you care about your brothers and sisters and something good happens in their lives, then you rejoice with them. A healthy body feels both pain and joy. So does a healthy church. It’s how we grow, as each member fulfils their part in what God has called us to as a body.

Take aways

1.      Unity with Christ means community with Christians. It’s not an option.

2.      Attitudes to avoid, “I don’t belong,” and “They don’t belong.”

3.      An attitude to adopt, caring for each other.

When we do these things we will be a healthy body and God will be able to use us in his work in the world.